Sunset Hill - Nautilus Homes | Luxury Custom Home Builders Sarasota, Florida

Sunset Hill

McClellan Park, Sarasota, Florida | 2025 | 4,361 sqft
Framed by mature trees and nestled within Sarasota’s historic McClellan Park, Sunset Hill is a home shaped by a deep understanding of, and sensibility for, its setting—reflecting the charm of the neighborhood, the rhythm of downtown living, and the client’s vision of entertaining, connection, and family life. Every decision—from site strategy to spatial flow—was made with intention: to support a lifestyle centered on warmth, community, and a strong sense of place.
Core Concept
A coastal contemporary home, thoughtfully attuned to its site, where the setting becomes an opportunity for light, connection, and refined family living.
Awards

2019 Aurora Award for Interior Detailing – Grand

2019 Aurora Award for Best Custom Home – Silver

2020 Best in American Living Awards Best Custom Home 4,001-5,000 sq. ft.

At its core, the project is a masterclass in leveraging zoning and code to unlock the full potential of a complex site. Though landlocked, the home lives like waterfront—offering openness, privacy, and expansive sunset views. Placing the pool in the front yard, within the 25-foot setback, redefines the entry experience. It captures the western light and sets a relaxed, resort-like tone from the very first step inside the gate. Paired with a rear-loaded garage, accessed discreetly via the side setback, the layout transforms the site’s limitations into its greatest assets. Architecture and landscape take center stage, while the full buildable envelope is maximized without compromise.

A natural rise of eight feet from front to back—rare in Sarasota—was embraced as an opportunity. Site walls function as both retaining structures and architectural elements, elevating the pool terrace and entry by over four feet to align with the main interior floor level. The result is a fluid connection between indoors and out: kitchen, dining, and living spaces unfold onto the terrace, blurring boundaries and enhancing everyday rituals as well as social gatherings.

Architecturally, the home is coastal contemporary: open yet composed, airy yet grounded. Clarity in the massing tells a story of the inhabitants from the first glance, while the interior planning offers spatial generosity and ease. The interiors echo this sensibility with a palette that is soft, natural, and tactile—serene without being neutral. The landscape design provides a lush tropical frame, softening edges and reinforcing privacy through layered plantings rather than enclosure.

Ultimately, Sunset Hill is not defined by any single gesture, but by the way the home reflects its owners. Their gracious, family-centered nature informed every layer of design—resulting in a space that feels deeply personal, tailored for connection and ease, and perfectly suited for gathering, unwinding, and watching the sun slip behind the trees from the comfort of home.

Contemporary home glows with warmth and personality.

Core Concept

Minimal and mindful while exuding a definitive statement of character.

Featured In

Herald Tribune

Awards

SRQ Magazine Home of the Year Best Renovation

Tim Siebert has been a driving force in the Sarasota School of Architecture since the early 1950’s. We had the rare opportunity to make enhancements to one of Siesta Key’s original dwellings in The Sanderling Club. This home, coined the Ness Home after the owners that worked with Tim Siebert, a Sarasota school of architecture pioneer, in the early 70’s, is modest in AC square footage yet boastful in history and design. It was originally built in 1958 in what was a cutting-edge technology of the time “lambolithic”, solid poured concrete, construction technique pioneered by the original builder John Lambie. We removed all of the epoxy floors from inside and replaced them with 4’x4′ Kerlite tiles. These are 1/8″ thick porcelain tiles with a 1/32″ grout joint. The final product is a seamless, perfectly white floor. The baseboard trims were replaced with brushed aluminum. This made for a clean look in keeping with the overall design.


The landscaping and hardscape were in desperate need of an update. The addition of a covered full outdoor kitchen, a new spa, and a landscape/hardscape that is as artistic as the home and client it serves. The concrete elements were created using shells that were artfully spread into the concrete. The space will serve as a home to a beautiful and loving family for many years to come.

You deserve extraordinary.

The first step is sharing your vision of your “personal oasis” with us, so we can bring it to life. Contact us by filling out the information below.